Kirkus Reviews QR Code
WISHES FOR LITTLE ONE by Sandra Magsamen


by Sandra Magsamen ; illustrated by Sandra Magsamen

Pub Date: April 1st, 2020
ISBN: 978-1-4926-9103-7
Publisher: Sourcebooks Wonderland

A baby-shower gift book for attendees to fill with wishes for the new arrival.

Magsamen’s latest is difficult to pin down. Only the final two spreads are meant for the enscribed wishes, so the rest is a picture book, per se, although a saccharine one seemingly directed at babies but meant for grown-ups. “We’ve gathered to shower you with love my dear… // and we made a book of wishes for you to hear! // We are your family, your friends and your neighbors too… // we are so excited to welcome you!” These verses are punctuated with Magsamen’s characteristic illustrations of stylized animals and simple shapes (stars, hearts, the sun) outlined in dashed-line “stitches.” The visual prominence of the animals can make it difficult at first for readers or listeners to realize that they aren’t the “we” used in the text. And once the book reaches the blank two pages for personalized sentiments (“So, as you read these wishes written just for you, / please remember that wishes really do come true!”), one can only assume that the writing style will change from the bouncy rhymes to plain text written for the parents and not the child, and their attention will likely be lost.

It’s difficult to imagine a child enjoying this treacly memento, whatever their age; even parents-to-be may be turned off.

(Gift book. 0-2, adult)